Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in NAFTA
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 2157
  • 0 Comments
  • Print

Canada Needs to Prepare for Negotiations on NAFTA

b2ap3_thumbnail_dreamstime_l_75398427.jpg

The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), came into effect on January 1, 1994, creating the largest free trade region in the world. It was designed to generate economic growth and help raise the standard of living for the people of all three member countries.

“By any measure the NAFTA has been a success by serving as a basis to grow both trilateral and bilateral North American relationships and the results speak for themselves. This integration helps maximize our capabilities and make our economies more innovative and competitive. In 1993, trilateral trade within the North American region was over US$288 billion. In 2015, our total trilateral merchandise trade amounted to over US$ 1.0 trillion.” (Source: Government of Canada Global Affairs Canada website). This is a more than threefold increase since 1993.

During the recent US election, Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump frequently spoke about the need to renegotiate NAFTA. They commonly highlighted the impact that “bad trade deals” as they were framed, had on American industry. As the election campaign unfolded, Hillary Clinton fell into line with her opponents on this issue. While the subject of renegotiating NAFTA has come up before, this time will likely be different. Here’s why.

Donald Trump has already stated that one of his major priorities is to create jobs in America. He campaigned with the slogan “Make America Great Again.” A big part of making America great again is bringing back jobs that were lost to other countries. This message resonated strongly with working class people living in “rust belt” states. In fact, the race for the Presidency was decided in Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. These states turned their backs on the Democrats and voted for Donald Trump. To maintain the support of working class Americans in these states, Mr. Trump will have to demonstrate that he is trying to bring back jobs to these states. To better understand the challenges of people living in cities in this area, who have lost their jobs, I encourage everyone to read Hillbilly Elegy by J.D. Vance (see my blog on the book http://www.dantranscon.com/index.php/blog?view=entry&id=253 ).

This is a region that contained coal mines, steel mills and many automotive manufacturing plants that are no longer in operation. During the election, Donald Trump frequently made some pointed comments about how many good jobs in the auto industry, and other industries, have migrated to Mexico. Of course, the province of Ontario also has thousands of jobs in this sector. Since the President-elect’s mission will be “America First,” it is likely that he will look carefully at the jobs located in Ontario that can be brought back to the “rust belt” and possibly other states. His priority will not be protecting Canadian jobs at the expense of American jobs.

Canadians need to begin thinking not only about jobs in automotive plants but also jobs in the automotive supply chain plants (i.e. companies that supply tires, molded plastic products, metal stampings, glass products, engines, brakes and so many other parts). Of course, any changes to the Canadian auto industry or any other industry that could be affected by changes to NAFTA, would have direct impacts on the Canadian Transportation industry.

It is common for politicians to make promises during an election campaign and then change or forget them afterward. It is very likely that Mr. Trump will launch a major infrastructure initiative to create jobs by rebuilding airports, bridges and highways. However, these types of jobs are temporary. It is also likely that Mr. Trump and his team will be looking for some “quick wins” in industries where factories can be re-opened and jobs can be repatriated to the United States (i.e. US-based automotive or automotive supply plants that are underutilized or sitting empty). Bringing American blue collar workers back to work would provide some high profile wins as he looks ahead to the election in 2020.

The bottom line is that the Canadian and Ontario governments and industry stakeholders should begin planning in earnest for the upcoming NAFTA negotiations that will likely take place early in 2017. Canada is a country that is very dependent on trade, particularly with the United States. Canadian leaders should begin looking at the potential trade-offs so that they protect Canadian jobs and the economy from potential shocks that may not be too far down the road.

 

To stay up to date on Best Practices in Freight Management, follow me on Twitter @DanGoodwill, join the Freight Management Best Practices group on LinkedIn and subscribe to Dan’s Daily Transportation Newspaper (http://paper.li/DanGoodwill/1342211466).

0

Comments

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Friday, 29 March 2024

Most Recent Posts

Search


Tag Cloud

Driving for Profit TMS Social Media LCV's Right Shoring BlueGrace Logistics Grocery Tracy Matura Loblaw CSA scores Regina Toronto Maple Leafs Comey Uber Freight Associates shipper-carrier collaboration energy efficiency Sales Management NS Toronto business security natural disasters Broker Amazon Doug Nix driver shortages US Auto Sales Deferred Packaging Dedicated Contract Carriage Ferromex pipelines economic outlook YRCW Swift Sales Training freight RFP Education ProMiles Werner broker bonds digital freight matching UP Trucker Protest Training technology Value Proposition asset management Railway Association of Canada home delivery transportation newspaper KCS LinkedIn 2014 freight volumes Retail dark stores FCPC 3PLTL economy BNSF transportation news dimensional pricing autonomous vehicles JB Hunt driverless Harper Davos speech USMCA Impeachment Politics Shipper coaching Wal-Mart Crude Oil by Rail CITA Shipper Pulse Survey selling trucking companies EBOR 2014 economic forecast MBA solutions provider Spanx Freight Capacity Training New Hires Online grocery shopping fuel surcharge cars marketing LTL FuelQuest Global Transportation Hub Consulting freight marketplace Transcom Fleet Leasing online shopping e-commerce freight rate increases Business Development Fire Phone USA Truck Otto $75000 bond Yield Improvement NAFTA Trump truck driver capacity shortages Transportation Buying Trends Survey Freight Driver Shortage Tariffs Muhammad Ali Justice Warehousing Crisis management Whole Foods 2013 Economic Forecast computer cyber security 2014 freight forecast Finance and Transportation Digitization freight payment freight audit shipping wine home delibery CP Rail Cleveland Cavaliers Infrastructure Hockey CSA the future of transportation intermodal Donald Trump US Manufacturing Electric Vehicles Canadian Transportation & Logistics 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad Failure shipper-carrier roundtable Colilers International Global experience truck drivers Job satisfaction Conway laptop CSX cheap oil 3PL Canada U.S. trade Business Strategy trucking company acquisitions routing guide Leafs freight cost savings tanker cars shipping broker security Career Advice Life Lessons Surety bond automation Business Transformation Strategy Success Rate per Mile Twitter drones Success failure entrepreneur Schneider Logistics Software Advice freight payment Transplace Emergent Strategy Carriers Canada Derek Singleton small parcel professional drivers freight transportation conference Trucking Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration Covid-19 freight broker Entrepreneur Truckload Omni Channel computer security dynamic pricing Freight Matching Rotman School of Business recession Canadian freight market financial management Canada's global strategy Celadon Freight Recession APL autos New York Times Doug Davis robotics Management derailments NCC TransForce future of freight industry Microsoft President Obama Dan Goodwill network optimization Transportation service US Election Social Media in Transportation mentoring Adrian Gonzalez risk management transportation audit bulk shipping Freight Carriers Association of Canada FMS TMP Worldwide Bobby Harris Packaging hiring process Canadian Protests FCA Anti-Vax economic forecasts for 2012 freight forwarders Canadian economy peak season Map-21 Freight Management freight agreements Search engine optimization Habs Retail transportation supply chain management last mile delivery Inbound Transportation David Tuttle CN Dedicated Trucking FMCSA small business Transportation University of Tennessee trade Masters in Logistics capacity shortage IANA freight bid Freight contracts MPG freight transportation in 2011 Blockchain Facebook Freight Shuttle System ShipMax CN Rail Accessorial Charges Load broker Business skills business start-up Rail truck capacity freight costs General Motors Distribution driver pay driver Sales Hudsons Bay Company consumer centric Stephen Harper Trade Vision China buying trucking companies Coronavirus Freight Rates Outsourcing Sales US Economy US Housing Market Government carrier conference 360ideaspace customer engagement Canadian truckers Montreal Canadiens shipper-carrier contracts NMFC Geopolitics employee termination computer protection Digital Freight Networks Leadership freight transportation CRM rail safety freight audit Transloading Keystone Pipeline 2015 Economic Forecast Scott Monty Reshoring Transport Capital Partners (TCP) RFP Sales Strategy Load Boards Climate Change ELD Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC Blogging

Blog Archives

March
February
December
October
September
August
June
May
April
March
January