Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog

The two previous blogs in this series highlighted the critical role that the rails play in transporting crude oil. They also noted that the surge in derailments is raising serious questions about the safety of using rail transportation. In addition, as a result the large drop in the price per barrel, below the estimated breakeven cost level, this raises concerns about the ongoing economic viability of moving crude oil by rail. This blog will focus on what can be done to improve rail safety and the economics of rail transportation.

Improve the Safety of Rail Transportation

The key stakeholders on this issue are tank car manufacturers, energy producers, railroads and governments. They each have a responsibility to protect the safety of the public. It should be pointed out that Lac Megantic, Quebec, the site of the worst crude oil rail disaster, has a population of less than 6000 people. There were 47 people who perished in that rail disaster and the cost to clean up and rebuild the downtown where the train hit is projected to be $400 million. In other words, if a disaster of this nature was to hit a mid-size or major city, the cost in lives and dollars could be of an extraordinary magnitude. Since these large stakeholders collectively are deriving billions of dollars in revenue, profits and taxes from this sector, they have a major responsibility to address the safety issue. The following is a summary of what has been done, how these changes are working out and what still needs to be done.

Change the Composition of the Oil

Under regulations adopted last year and to be put into effect in April, oil companies in North Dakota will have to remove volatile gases such as propane from their crude before pumping it into a rail car. This is estimated to add another 10 cents a barrel to the cost. In April, a regulation in North Dakota requires oil to be kept at a vapor pressure below 13.7 pounds per square inch goes into effect. This process known as conditioning, which companies can use to meet that standard, is the “bare minimum” step to lower volatility.

...
Hits: 3417
0
Continue reading 0 Comments

The business case for shipping crude oil by rail was outlined in the previous blog. The rapid growth in the production of oil in Canada and the United States coupled with the flexibility and efficiency of shipping crude oil by rail has seen the volumes moving via this mode increase 5000 percent growth rate over the past 5 years. Crude oil by rail has grown from almost zero to eleven percent of the revenue of the class 1 railroads during this period. Two things have had a dramatic impact on this business model. They are the rapid and huge drop in the price of a barrel of oil and the level of derailments that have made this a major safety hazard. This blog will focus on the current economics of moving oil by rail. 

The Cost of Producing Crude Oil

The cost required to lift crude oil and maintain oil wells, equipment, and facilities is called production cost or lifting cost. A Market Realist article published in January 2015 draws information from the EIA’s (Energy Information Administration) 2009 report that shows the production cost of crude oil was ~$12 per barrel for the United States and ~$10 per barrel for the Middle East. But recent consensus says these costs could range from $20 to $25 per barrel.

The Cost of Shipping Crude Oil by Rail

The cost to transport a barrel of crude oil ranges between $10 and $20 depending on the origin and destination locations. It must be kept in mind that some of the major rails in the U.S. and Canada have been adding a $1000 surcharge per tanker car in cases where old DOT-111 cars are used. This adds about $1.50 to the per barrel cost. An article published in the February 2 Toronto Globe & Mail stated that recent developments are casting doubt on the business case for shipping crude oil by rail. Since rail costs are about double the cost of shipping via pipeline, “it is unclear if high costs make shipping by rail a money-making mode of transport for producers.” It should be noted that the above-mentioned breakeven analysis doesn’t reflect the additional costs that will come from the necessary upgrades to improve rail safety (as outlined in the next blog). These improvements are expected to add billions of dollars to shipping costs.

...
Hits: 2781
0
Continue reading 0 Comments

Volume of Crude Oil Moving by Rail in the United States and Canada

U.S. crude oil production has risen sharply in recent years, with much of the increased output moving by rail. In 2008, U.S. Class I railroads originated 9,500 carloads of crude oil. In 2013, they originated 407,761 carloads. In the first half of 2014, it was 229,798 carloads. Much of the recent increase in crude oil production has been in North Dakota, where crude oil production rose from an average of 81,000 barrels per day in 2003 to more than one million barrels per day by mid-2014, making it the second-largest oil producing state. Crude oil output in Texas, the top crude oil producing state, was relatively flat from 2003 to 2009, but has skyrocketed since then, exceeding three million barrels per day by mid-2014. Canada ships 3.2 million barrels a day via pipeline and 215,000 barrels a day via rail.

Assuming, for simplicity, that each rail tank car holds about 30,000 gallons (714 barrels) of crude oil, the 229,798 carloads of crude oil originated by U.S. Class I railroads in the first half of 2014 was equivalent to 900,000 barrels per day moving by rail. According to EIA data, total U.S. domestic crude oil production in the first half of 2014 was 8.2 million barrels per day, so the rail share was around 11 percent of the total.

Advantages of Transporting Crude Oil by Rail

Pipelines have traditionally transported most crude oil, but in recent years railroads have become critical players. In addition to the fact that railroads provide transportation capacity in many areas where pipeline capacity is insufficient, railroads offer a number of other advantages for transporting crude oil:

...
Hits: 3081
0
Continue reading 0 Comments

Most Recent Posts

Search


Tag Cloud

transportation news Montreal Canadiens LTL YRCW bulk shipping Social Media Freight Shuttle System intermodal UP professional drivers Success failure entrepreneur Social Media in Transportation broker bonds Coronavirus drones freight cost savings Werner Retail transportation Packaging LCV's Railway Association of Canada Freight Matching dynamic pricing cheap oil Transportation Buying Trends Survey customer engagement Life Lessons freight transportation truck driver Covid-19 CITA Shipper Pulse Survey tanker cars selling trucking companies FuelQuest recession future of freight industry Bobby Harris Map-21 freight RFP Business Strategy TMP Worldwide Reshoring Shipper Entrepreneur driverless Consulting Omni Channel US Economy EBOR Associates shipper-carrier roundtable Scott Monty driver APL Canadian truckers Toronto Maple Leafs computer Canadian Protests Dedicated Contract Carriage shipper-carrier contracts Doug Davis Yield Improvement freight broker mentoring Failure TransForce Canada Politics rail safety Masters in Logistics FMS Sales Strategy Stephen Harper Trade Vision Crude Oil by Rail BlueGrace Logistics Load broker Rail Donald Trump TMS Freight Carriers Association of Canada Colilers International Right Shoring Derek Singleton Freight freight costs Sales Management business security Sales Training consumer centric peak season Inbound Transportation Digitization US Auto Sales carrier conference NCC coaching laptop Blockchain Canadian freight market Freight Capacity Loblaw energy efficiency Outsourcing Sales Uber Freight capacity shortages Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC Toronto Value Proposition dimensional pricing Business Transformation Strategy Deferred Packaging Electric Vehicles Comey Crisis management autos small parcel Schneider Logistics Business Development Transportation Global Transportation Hub Finance and Transportation Broker Success Accessorial Charges Government US Election Trump Muhammad Ali Canadian Transportation & Logistics Transportation service ShipMax home delibery Retail Grocery CN buying trucking companies robotics Education driver pay Digital Freight Networks trade $75000 bond 360ideaspace solutions provider Sales Trucking network optimization Blogging broker security Transport Capital Partners (TCP) Whole Foods Carriers computer security Training New Hires Freight Rates Transloading Leadership fuel surcharge Microsoft freight transportation in 2011 2014 freight forecast David Tuttle technology 2013 Economic Forecast Harper Davos speech Keystone Pipeline Canada's global strategy Warehousing IANA Ferromex US Housing Market 3PLTL Facebook 2015 Economic Forecast Freight Management transportation newspaper freight bid Celadon Rotman School of Business Freight contracts Habs Cleveland Cavaliers ELD Canadian economy shipping wine economic outlook derailments freight payment pipelines Hudsons Bay Company cars LinkedIn online shopping dark stores truck drivers Dan Goodwill Climate Change Canada U.S. trade Emergent Strategy driver shortages Transplace FMCSA KCS employee termination US Manufacturing Swift NS economic forecasts for 2012 MBA Otto last mile delivery CP Rail BNSF Twitter NAFTA hiring process FCA Management freight transportation conference automation Regina Spanx Load Boards CN Rail freight rate increases General Motors freight payment freight audit USMCA FCPC Driving for Profit small business 2014 freight volumes home delivery USA Truck Tariffs MPG natural disasters Software Advice Conway Hockey CRM Business skills Freight Recession Career Advice computer protection JB Hunt capacity shortage Doug Nix economy freight agreements Justice Surety bond Truckload Distribution asset management Rate per Mile 3PL President Obama China Training cyber security supply chain management Geopolitics Adrian Gonzalez freight forwarders shipping e-commerce NMFC ProMiles freight audit Leafs Amazon New York Times CSA financial management routing guide Fire Phone Driver Shortage Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration business start-up transportation audit Search engine optimization Transcom Fleet Leasing Online grocery shopping CSA scores Trucker Protest Wal-Mart freight marketplace Global experience truck capacity trucking company acquisitions Infrastructure Anti-Vax Tracy Matura risk management Job satisfaction marketing digital freight matching the future of transportation autonomous vehicles shipper-carrier collaboration 2014 economic forecast Dedicated Trucking University of Tennessee RFP CSX 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad Impeachment

Blog Archives

March
February
December
October
September
August
June
May
April
March
January