Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in Freight Cost Savings
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 22893
  • 0 Comments
  • Print

Is your Freight Transportation Strategy in Alignment with your Business Strategy?

One of the most enjoyable aspects of our work as consultants is that my colleagues and I have an opportunity to visit companies in a variety of industries.  We typically are engaged to help businesses that have issues with freight management.  While some of our clients may be Best-in-Class when it comes to manufacturing or retail, they are often not as skilled in managing freight transportation. 

We often notice that their freight strategies are not aligned with their business strategies.  In fact, they often inhibit these companies from achieving the bottom line results that they are so desperately seeking.  Here are some of the things that we commonly observe.

Many companies focus on the outbound movement of their freight to their DCs, retail stores or customers.  They let their vendors control all or some of the deliveries of raw materials or finished products to their main manufacturing or distribution facility.  This can produce several negative financial impacts. 

For many vendors, freight is a profit centre.  They mark up their freight costs and include the inflated cost in the landed cost.  By not having control of inbound freight movements, this restricts the leverage a company can have with its carriers when it comes time to negotiate freight rates.  It also limits the opportunity to perform consolidations to further reduce freight costs.

We also observe that a number of companies are not providing their clients with the level of service they require.  This can occur for several reasons.  The carrier may be picking up or delivering the shipper’s products at the wrong time.  Their transportation network is not aligned to the needs of some of its customers.  A late pickup or delivery, on a consistent basis, can mean the loss of customers.  It may result in wasted warehouse or store expense as the crews stand around waiting for the freight to arrive.  In addition, carriers may be holding freight on their docks to build better loads to certain destinations.   They do this in the hope that shippers that do not carefully track the on-time service performance will not notice these late deliveries.

Some companies do not have the technology in place to effectively manage their freight transportation.  As customer orders come in, shipment requests are placed on their vendors.   We will observe multiple shipments coming from the same vendor, going to the same distribution facility, on the same day.  The technology is not there to provide the visibility to identify these situations as they are occurring so these shipments can be consolidated into one large courier or LTL shipment.  Without good technology, their shipping personnel may not select the correct mode or the best carrier at the best price.  These shippers are simply overpaying for freight.

Inadequate metrics and KPIs are often associated with weak information systems.  While companies will have good financial and operations metrics to manage their business, they will have rudimentary (e.g. Freight Cost as a percent of Sales) KPIs to manage their freight spend.  The company’s freight budget may include the total projected freight spend by division, but it won’t include breakdowns by mode or by freight cost (e.g. line haul, fuel surcharge, accessorial charges).  It is no wonder that without the technology and information tools, freight management is disconnected from business management.

Sadly, the auditing of carrier freight invoices is still done in a haphazard way in some companies.  Carriers will make billing errors from time to time.  These errors can have lasting impacts on a company’s bottom line if they are not detected and corrected.

While many companies jumped on the “freight bid bandwagon” during the Great Recession, we frequently hear about transportation managers who are not skilled in conducting these exercises.   This is an area where we often receive complaints from carriers.  Transport companies take a dim view of allocating time and resources to a poorly constructed bid that doesn’t contain sufficient data, correct product weights and dimensions, seasonality factors and other key freight related issues.  This can lead to a “garbage in/garbage out” scenario.  Some carriers simply don’t bother responding to a poorly constructed bid that is designed to “lay the hammer” on their incumbent carriers.  Shippers are often not well served when they tender their freight to poor performing “bottom feeders.”  A few months later, these shippers may sheepishly go crawling back to their previous incumbent carriers.  In addition to disruption, lost productive time and customer ill will, making these changes is harmful to a business’ bottom line.

While freights costs can represent 2 to 5% of a company’s revenues, they often don’t receive the attention they deserve from an organizational perspective.  We so often find the manager responsible for transportation wearing multiple hats.  Freight is a “necessary evil” and doesn’t receive the attention or the respect it deserves.  While companies will go out and hire top notch sales and engineering professionals, they will “force fit” unqualified individuals into the role of Transportation Manager.  Without the knowledge, skills and resources, the company gets what it deserves - - poor performance.

For an item that can be so important to a company’s bottom line, it is puzzling to see so many organizations not give transportation the attention it requires.  On the other hand, for companies that do put a priority on the management of freight transportation and adopt Best-in-Class freight management strategies, this can be a differentiator to increase margins, market share and profitability.

 

 

Freight bids and a variety of other topics will be discussed at the October 16 2013 Surface Transportation Summit (www.surfacetransportationsummit.com).  Click on the link to see the agenda and speakers.  

Tagged in: Distribution
0

Comments

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Friday, 29 March 2024

Most Recent Posts

Search


Tag Cloud

energy efficiency Anti-Vax freight forwarders derailments driverless Trump RFP Doug Nix Freight Management 2014 freight forecast Success failure entrepreneur China Warehousing Canadian truckers supply chain management Rotman School of Business Masters in Logistics Doug Davis LinkedIn Justice Management the future of transportation Driver Shortage Social Media robotics Packaging broker security digital freight matching Donald Trump recession CN Werner Toronto freight transportation US Housing Market freight RFP Coronavirus Transportation service economy Muhammad Ali Global experience Retail transportation Dedicated Contract Carriage 2014 freight volumes Career Advice Montreal Canadiens UP Truckload peak season 2014 economic forecast 360ideaspace Value Proposition driver pay Freight Capacity solutions provider Deferred Packaging Sales Management cyber security home delibery Railway Association of Canada capacity shortages home delivery 3PLTL Fire Phone Inbound Transportation Finance and Transportation financial management small parcel CN Rail carrier conference selling trucking companies employee termination EBOR online shopping Covid-19 Distribution trucking company acquisitions Rail Dedicated Trucking Whole Foods Retail shipper-carrier contracts future of freight industry US Economy computer security Comey freight transportation conference Harper Davos speech routing guide dimensional pricing Canadian economy Regina Associates Business Development Transplace dark stores Impeachment 2013 Economic Forecast CSX Business Transformation Strategy Freight contracts Business skills Transloading FCA CITA Shipper Pulse Survey Consulting freight rate increases Sales Training IANA Twitter Government coaching small business Ferromex US Auto Sales Global Transportation Hub Surety bond Training New Hires truck driver freight audit Infrastructure Freight NAFTA cars automation Success Dan Goodwill Keystone Pipeline ShipMax Reshoring risk management truck capacity Canadian Transportation & Logistics Schneider Logistics ELD Canadian Protests YRCW Spanx business start-up USMCA transportation audit computer freight payment freight audit network optimization pipelines Uber Freight driver Digitization Adrian Gonzalez Canada shipper-carrier collaboration drones buying trucking companies Microsoft Social Media in Transportation University of Tennessee Load broker capacity shortage Broker Failure freight agreements Blockchain truck drivers BNSF MPG Habs Blogging Outsourcing Sales CP Rail natural disasters fuel surcharge Accessorial Charges Software Advice NCC business security FMS Wal-Mart LCV's Freight Rates Crisis management Tracy Matura transportation news TMP Worldwide Trucker Protest ProMiles Politics Climate Change Hockey driver shortages Freight Shuttle System Freight Carriers Association of Canada Cleveland Cavaliers Emergent Strategy Derek Singleton Scott Monty CSA scores intermodal Swift 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad rail safety cheap oil BlueGrace Logistics President Obama freight marketplace freight transportation in 2011 Transport Capital Partners (TCP) US Manufacturing Online grocery shopping tanker cars FCPC economic outlook customer engagement Load Boards Tariffs trade MBA Geopolitics Driving for Profit Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC Carriers Celadon Transportation Sales Search engine optimization Omni Channel autonomous vehicles Bobby Harris freight payment Facebook Crude Oil by Rail FMCSA asset management e-commerce professional drivers Yield Improvement 2015 Economic Forecast freight broker Leafs FuelQuest Loblaw Transportation Buying Trends Survey Electric Vehicles freight costs Toronto Maple Leafs Sales Strategy autos Canada U.S. trade Leadership freight cost savings Shipper Freight Matching Canadian freight market Business Strategy broker bonds laptop shipping wine Trucking Stephen Harper Trade Vision JB Hunt USA Truck US Election NS TransForce economic forecasts for 2012 New York Times 3PL Entrepreneur Digital Freight Networks transportation newspaper Amazon Colilers International Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration NMFC bulk shipping computer protection Transcom Fleet Leasing General Motors TMS shipping consumer centric freight bid Life Lessons hiring process last mile delivery $75000 bond Map-21 Conway Rate per Mile Training Freight Recession Otto marketing APL David Tuttle CSA Job satisfaction Grocery dynamic pricing Education shipper-carrier roundtable mentoring LTL CRM Canada's global strategy technology Hudsons Bay Company KCS Right Shoring

Blog Archives

March
February
December
October
September
August
June
May
April
March
January