Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in Freight Bids
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 14674
  • 0 Comments
  • Print

More on Shipper-Carrier Collaboration and Freight Bids

In last week’s blog, I shared some ideas from the recent SCL – CITA annual conference on how to improve shipper- carrier collaboration.  Various suggestions were proposed by a panel consisting of two leading shippers and two major Canadian carriers.  Some other thoughts were expressed during other tracks that day.

The panelists presented some suggestions that came out of a joint meeting between the Ontario Trucking Association and the Canadian Industrial Transportation Association.  Here is more of what they had to say.

Removing Waste from the Shipper and Carrier’s Operation

During the panel discussion it was suggested that it is through trust, communication and dialogue, rather than through an RFP, that opportunities to remove waste from a shipper’s operation can be identified, discussed and solved.  The RFP process is typically too rigid to allow for a meaningful exchange of ideas and for the development of action plans. 

Since the focus in an RFP is typically on rates and service, it doesn’t create a forum for dedicated problem resolution.  Moreover, by not creating project teams, action plans and time lines to remove waste, the inefficiencies typically doesn’t get extracted.  The shipper continues to perform the same functions, in the same way, with its existing and/or new carriers.  Drivers continue to be pick up half full loads since opportunities to consolidate freight or change pick-up dates are missed. As one trucking executive mentioned, the savings generated from these types of initiatives can be much larger than the two percent saved as a result of the freight bid.

Similarly, the process often doesn’t allow for a thoughtful discussion of how a shipper’s prospective partners are employing their assets, where they have empty miles, where they have backhaul and/or the location of drop yards where they have a supply of assets.   It doesn’t allow for engaging in a dialogue on where each business is going and how and what each company could do to make the marriage work more effectively, particularly over a multi-year horizon.

Carrier Site Visits

One carrier highlighted the importance in having shippers visit the premises of their potential carriers.  The visit can allow for a review of their carriers’ customer service and IT capabilities, meeting key operational personnel and discussing equipment requirements.   

Quarterly Reviews

One suggestion that has been made many times over the past decade is for shippers and carriers to conduct quarterly reviews.  To make these meetings productive, the two parties need to meet on a consistent basis, set up appropriate KPIs that relate directly to the key problems or waste areas, and follow through to improve the results. 

Performance improvements don’t just happen by themselves.  They occur if both parties share information and speak openly about obstacles, both in terms of people and process.  Carriers need to feel comfortable enough to offer ideas on their own initiative, even if these ideas lead to fewer but hopefully better shipments.  Shippers on their side need to take action on suggestions that make good business sense for both sides.  The scorecard should specifically contain a KPI for both carrier innovation and shipper responsiveness.  If one side does not have a vested interest in generating or acting on cost saving opportunities, this will limit participation.  On the other hand, carriers that come up with solid, actionable cost reduction ideas, resulting in quantifiable savings, should be rewarded.  These rewards can take several forms such as reduced carrier operating costs, shipper rates and/or continued shipper support and contract extensions. 

Engineered Solutions

Finally, shippers should facilitate and look for “engineered” solutions.  Carriers should be providing customized (rather than “cookie-cutter”) proposals for their clients.  They should be highlighting that they are providing value-added solutions that demonstrate a superior way of serving the unique needs of their clients.

0

Comments

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Tuesday, 19 March 2024

Most Recent Posts

Search


Tag Cloud

tanker cars Carriers Justice Reshoring robotics Success economic forecasts for 2012 freight costs 3PLTL shipper-carrier contracts Impeachment 2014 economic forecast Global Transportation Hub Surety bond Software Advice Sales Training Loblaw Government drones freight payment freight audit economic outlook Regina Harper Davos speech Warehousing Business Development Derek Singleton Hudsons Bay Company US Election Packaging FMCSA cars EBOR cheap oil KCS the future of transportation Education Rate per Mile Toronto Maple Leafs Canada U.S. trade Emergent Strategy dark stores Dan Goodwill Freight Matching routing guide TransForce energy efficiency FCPC Canadian truckers recession LinkedIn Rotman School of Business Business Transformation Strategy Covid-19 Habs computer security small business Trucker Protest Railway Association of Canada Load Boards transportation news Adrian Gonzalez USA Truck NS home delibery US Economy Success failure entrepreneur Cleveland Cavaliers Job satisfaction Digitization University of Tennessee Transportation Buying Trends Survey RFP Freight Management freight forwarders technology Deferred Packaging autonomous vehicles shipper-carrier collaboration dynamic pricing New York Times Comey Entrepreneur trade freight transportation in 2011 MPG Wal-Mart Leafs Sales Management capacity shortages USMCA 2014 freight forecast IANA network optimization CRM shipper-carrier roundtable Stephen Harper Trade Vision CN Rail Dedicated Contract Carriage CSX Uber Freight MBA Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration broker security transportation audit Map-21 driverless Canadian Protests freight payment NMFC Crisis management Climate Change Whole Foods Dedicated Trucking Online grocery shopping Driver Shortage Career Advice APL truck capacity Swift truck drivers computer protection Keystone Pipeline Conway Anti-Vax freight transportation conference Business skills Politics Training New Hires ProMiles NCC customer engagement freight cost savings solutions provider Freight Rates natural disasters peak season Value Proposition 360ideaspace Canadian freight market CITA Shipper Pulse Survey Digital Freight Networks dimensional pricing Transportation service Retail transportation Management Canadian economy Transloading Freight Carriers Association of Canada economy driver pay Doug Davis Grocery business start-up Freight Blogging hiring process risk management Transplace Toronto derailments 3PL YRCW Load broker carrier conference Social Media online shopping FMS small parcel shipping Driving for Profit Life Lessons Search engine optimization transportation newspaper US Auto Sales Scott Monty Sales Canada's global strategy cyber security Yield Improvement TMP Worldwide trucking company acquisitions pipelines Trump autos fuel surcharge Celadon Canada President Obama automation ShipMax Trucking Leadership professional drivers laptop Masters in Logistics driver shortages Crude Oil by Rail Hockey Ferromex bulk shipping digital freight matching freight agreements Spanx BlueGrace Logistics TMS buying trucking companies Donald Trump computer e-commerce Social Media in Transportation Consulting Transport Capital Partners (TCP) asset management David Tuttle Amazon Transcom Fleet Leasing JB Hunt Canadian Transportation & Logistics Freight Capacity Schneider Logistics LCV's business security Twitter LTL Right Shoring broker bonds 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad Truckload FCA Doug Nix intermodal Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC Freight Shuttle System Distribution Omni Channel supply chain management Finance and Transportation Global experience Tariffs Microsoft freight bid US Housing Market Otto rail safety Montreal Canadiens employee termination freight marketplace coaching Business Strategy CSA Blockchain freight broker Electric Vehicles Coronavirus UP selling trucking companies Failure Muhammad Ali freight audit Outsourcing Sales Facebook Transportation capacity shortage Shipper Rail Freight Recession 2013 Economic Forecast Training General Motors consumer centric Associates mentoring shipping wine $75000 bond freight rate increases marketing FuelQuest Broker ELD driver financial management Sales Strategy Tracy Matura 2015 Economic Forecast Infrastructure CSA scores Colilers International Accessorial Charges Fire Phone Bobby Harris Freight contracts freight RFP BNSF freight transportation Inbound Transportation NAFTA CN Werner Retail CP Rail China home delivery truck driver last mile delivery future of freight industry Geopolitics US Manufacturing 2014 freight volumes

Blog Archives

March
February
December
October
September
August
June
May
April
March
January