Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Subscribe to this list via RSS Blog posts tagged in hiring process


Over the past few years, I have noticed a disturbing trend as I meet with both our shipper and carrier associates. They have changed their leadership team again. The VP of Transportation or Logistics (in manufacturing and retail organizations) or the President or other senior officer (in transportation organizations) has now been replaced multiple times. In fact, in some companies, they change executives like some people do spring cleaning in their homes. “It is out with old and in with the new.”

What is interesting for me is that in some cases, as an outside consultant, I have had the opportunity to work directly with the business leader and the company. I have been able to observe their performance and that of their superiors and subordinates. I have the following observations to share with you.

In some situations, the terminated business leader was doomed to fail. The expectations for the individual may not have been realistic. He or she may not have received the full support of the business owner or senior executive or the collaboration between them wasn't there. The departed person was charged with implementing the failed or poorly conceived vision of the business leader. The terminated executive “took the fall” for the unsuccessful business plan or weak leadership of his or her boss.

In other cases, the individual did not perform at the required level. He or she may have not had the required skills, did not fit with the company culture and/or did not work well with his or her peers. In some cases, there was an overreliance on specific subordinates who were not performing their jobs at an acceptable level. This overreliance and/or a poor hiring process cost the individual his or her job.

Hits: 233
Continue reading 0 Comments


Posted by on in Career Advice


Last week, I was watching the U.S. Democratic Party Town Hall on television that took place in South Carolina. A member of the audience stood up and asked Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont to talk about what he considers one of the most important traits of a leader. He replied that having a passion for what you do is a driving force for him. He then went on to amplify his response. That question and answer was quite revealing and has stayed with me ever since.

Two days later I received an e mail from Scott Monty who publishes a blog entitled The Full Monty ( ). Scott is an expert in Social Media. The title of his weekly blog was Passion. The fact that these two seemingly random events happened in the same week inspired me to write this blog.

As I reflect back on my over 45 years in the working world, the issue of passion has been a driving force for me. There have been times when I worked for some fine companies and great leaders. I got up in the morning and couldn’t wait to get to work. I was proud to represent my company and I was very driven to see the company succeed.

I am very happy to be running my own company at this stage of my career. I am very motivated to help our shipper clients save money on freight, to help our carrier clients improve their profitability and to help organize and host one of the best freight transportation conferences in Canada. I have a deep passion for all of these segments of the business.

Hits: 2037
Continue reading 0 Comments

How to Improve the Hiring Process

Posted by on in General

Last weekend I was struck by an interview on leadership lessons in The New York Times.  It appeared in the “Corner Office” column of the Sunday Business section.  The interview was conducted with Tracy Matura, general manager of the Smart car division of Mercedes-Benz USA.  During the interview, Tracy was asked a question about what she asks prospective candidates whom she is seeking to hire.  Here is what she said.

“Tell me who your favorite boss was and why, and tell me who your least-favorite boss was and why.” Tracy commented that this gives you a sense of what leadership style works best for this individual.  “I would also then ask them about a time they took a risk and failed.  I have never hired people who have told me they’ve never failed.  You don’t learn if you don’t fail.” 

The interviewer then challenged her on the issue of whether anyone ever admits that they have never failed.  Tracy responded by saying that people might say, “You know, I don’t think I’ve ever really had a complete failure.  Really.  I don’t even ask the question in terms of just business.  Everybody has had some failure in their life.”

This led the interviewer to try to understand the underlying rationale for the question.  This was her response.  “Here’s what I want:  My leadership style is to be transparent and authentic, so if you’re going to tell me you’ve never failed, then it makes me wonder if you always hide your failures.  I don’t like that - - surprises are bad for everybody.  I can’t fix or try to fix something I don’t know about.  Some people have that fear factor if they admit to failure, as if they say to themselves, “If I say I failed, she’s going  to think I’m a loser and not hire me.  Quite the opposite.”

While Ms. Matura’s comments reflect what she is looking for in a prospective employee, the person being interviewed has an obligation to try to determine the management style of the prospective boss.  In order to make this assessment, the interviewee needs to ask a similar set of questions.  “Tell me about the employees you hire with whom you have had the most successful relationship and why, and tell me about the employees you hired that were the least successful and why.  How would you describe your leadership style?  Please share with me some of your teams’ successes and failures.  How do you describe your goal-setting process, how do you measure results, how do you communicate those results and what is the performance review process?  Also, please describe the work environment that you try to create.”

Hits: 21789
Continue reading 0 Comments

Most Recent Posts


Tag Cloud

Tracy Matura MBA Business Strategy LinkedIn freight RFP Fire Phone solutions provider LCV's freight agreements Software Advice last mile delivery 2013 Economic Forecast Werner Carriers shipping wine transportation news UP e-commerce Freight contracts Freight Management Canadian freight market CN Rail shipper-carrier roundtable 360ideaspace Education Business skills customer engagement Politics Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration Job satisfaction carrier conference freight forwarders Hudsons Bay Company 2014 freight forecast marketing Dedicated Contract Carriage energy efficiency small business Emergent Strategy NCC Sales Management Truckload broker security tanker cars Training New Hires freight cost savings Warehousing consumer centric Canadian truckers US Auto Sales Amazon coaching capacity shortages FCPC freight transportation conference Outsourcing Sales KCS freight rate increases Cleveland Cavaliers Freight Recession Scott Monty Canada economy University of Tennessee shipper-carrier contracts FMS CRM US Election dynamic pricing freight payment freight audit Leadership Celadon bulk shipping Doug Davis New York Times derailments pipelines Infrastructure FMCSA US Housing Market freight audit Finance and Transportation Doug Nix CITA Shipper Pulse Survey Climate Change Loblaw Sales Training Whole Foods Map-21 future of freight industry Crisis management Blogging drones dimensional pricing JB Hunt Associates Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC shipper-carrier collaboration Global Transportation Hub Canadian economy USA Truck Distribution CN Success Colilers International CSA 3PL home delibery 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad Broker Masters in Logistics Business Transformation Strategy trade Ferromex business start-up Adrian Gonzalez freight transportation in 2011 transportation audit Rotman School of Business autonomous vehicles Freight 3PLTL peak season NAFTA US Economy Canada U.S. trade driver shortages Career Advice the future of transportation driver TMP Worldwide Stephen Harper Trade Vision Railway Association of Canada Transportation Success failure entrepreneur Spanx network optimization shipping FCA 2014 freight volumes Life Lessons routing guide Sales 2014 economic forecast Toronto transportation newspaper online shopping Wal-Mart EBOR Transportation service intermodal Grocery Reshoring Trump freight payment FuelQuest selling trucking companies economic forecasts for 2012 Load broker Search engine optimization TransForce Social Media cheap oil Training Freight Rates David Tuttle NS CP Rail automation fuel surcharge CSX Shipper Canadian Transportation & Logistics truck drivers employee termination Swift ProMiles Consulting Transloading Freight Matching Otto mentoring $75000 bond Dan Goodwill freight bid freight costs Rail Yield Improvement Inbound Transportation Conway Dedicated Trucking LTL Social Media in Transportation Derek Singleton Retail transportation President Obama Transportation Buying Trends Survey Trucking Comey Management professional drivers Packaging hiring process Freight Carriers Association of Canada financial management Keystone Pipeline Right Shoring Transcom Fleet Leasing Donald Trump Transport Capital Partners (TCP) Schneider Logistics Omni Channel APL freight transportation Twitter Entrepreneur RFP Rate per Mile 2015 Economic Forecast Canada's global strategy US Manufacturing Facebook Load Boards Muhammad Ali ShipMax Surety bond Global experience Bobby Harris NMFC Regina broker bonds MPG capacity shortage BlueGrace Logistics freight broker buying trucking companies TMS rail safety Transplace trucking company acquisitions Driving for Profit IANA Failure BNSF Microsoft CSA scores Harper Davos speech driverless Freight Shuttle System Freight Capacity Retail Crude Oil by Rail home delivery truck driver Driver Shortage robotics Deferred Packaging Accessorial Charges

Blog Archives