Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in Shipper-Carrier Collaboration
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 2890
  • 0 Comments
  • Print

Shipper-Carrier Collaboration is a Challenge in this Era of Tight Capacity

 

b2ap3_thumbnail_Stifel-2018-rate-increase-projections.jpg

On October 11, my company co-hosted the 2017 Surface Transportation Summit with my partners at Newcom Business Media. I am very pleased to report that we had another packed house for what has become the premier educational and networking event in Freight Transportation in Canada.

The day was again kicked off by one of Canada’s leading economists, Carlos Gomes of Scotiabank and by two investment analysts, Walter Spracklin, CFA, Equity Research Analyst - Transportation Sector, RBC Capital Markets and John Larkin, CFA, Managing Director and Head, Transportation Capital Markets Research, Stifel Financial Corp., who provided an American perspective. These gentlemen highlighted that 2018 will be a year of economic growth. This economic growth, coupled with the ELD mandate and the limited supply of quality drivers in the United States, will translate into tight capacity and higher freight rates.

One of the slides that caught my eye was the one inserted above from the John Larkin presentation. John’s views are consistent with what one of the largest US trucking operators, J.B. Hunt Transport Services, is telling its shipper customers. They are advising them to budget for transportation cost increases as high as “10 percent or more” as the peak fall distribution season and electronic logging mandate intensify a driver shortage. “This is one of the highest periods of turbulence and volatility in supply we have ever experienced, and we don’t think it will abate any time soon,” John Roberts, president and CEO, and Shelley Simpson, chief commercial officer, said in a letter to J.B. Hunt customers.

Capacity is limited, even with contracted core carriers. The subject of shipper-carrier collaboration was the focus of one of the afternoon breakout sessions. One of the issues that was highlighted is that even carriers with contracted rates, that have committed to supply capacity to their core customers, are not able to provide the required number of drivers, tractors and trailers this fall. In Canada, this has become a problem on cross-border truckload traffic out of Quebec and Ontario.

The Basic Options for Securing Capacity

This led into a discussion of the available options to obtain capacity. The option of adding more backup carriers was seen as of limited value. Backup carriers may be able to supply capacity on specific days, on specific lanes, when their volumes are soft. However, at the end of the month, they need to make their capacity available to their primary customers; shippers may not be able to rely on extra equipment from these carriers during their peak periods. Backup carriers will become more dependable if they receive consistent volumes, not a couple of extra loads at the end of the month or quarter.

Using load brokers is an option, but not necessarily an entirely reliable one. Load brokers work with their group of core carriers. These carriers have their own base of customers, of which brokers rank somewhere on the pecking order. They can be an option at times but they may not always be able to meet the specific needs of the shipper (i.e. performing trailer drops rather than live loading). Using the so-called “spot market” may work in times of excess capacity but when capacity tightens, rates can spike as they are now in some areas.

Another option is to establish a private fleet to move freight for certain customers and/or specific geographic areas. Running a private fleet is a significant undertaking, even if a company only runs a small fleet. Driver recruitment is an industrywide problem. Setting up a private fleet will require the shipper to address issues such as finding back haul traffic to ensure the economic viability of the fleet, buying or leasing equipment, fleet maintenance, insurance, fleet management and other concerns. Creating a private fleet is not for everyone.

Some shippers are trying to “throw money at the problem.” Certainly, carriers like shippers that pay premium rates and that pay their invoices quickly (i.e. within 15 days). But shippers must watch their bottom lines. Paying top dollar for freight and/or going on the “spot market” are costly solutions. With freight rates already on the rise, there is a limit to how much shippers can afford to pay for the assurance of capacity.

Other Options to Consider

During our discussion at the Summit, certain options came up for discussion. They included the following:

Dedicated Transportation

Shippers that are having trouble managing this problem can explore the possibility of outsourcing their freight operations to a dedicated contract carrier. While this may address the capacity issue, in some markets, the shipper must carefully compare the financial implications of this option against the status quo.

Freight Management Companies

Another choice is an extension of the freight broker option. Using a large freight management company provides the shipper access to a much broader range of carriers. This option can be particularly attractive on some of the harder to cover lanes. The top freight management companies may be aware of the small, less well-known carriers that may be just what a shipper needs in some situations. Since freight management companies add a markup to the costs of their carriers, this can be an expensive option for some shippers.

The Best Option

As our discussion ended, the attendees seem to agree on one of the most desirable paths forward. This is the idea that in this era of tight capacity, there is a great need for shippers and carriers to be frank on how they can best work together. As one of the attendees stated, it is better for a carrier to be forthright and tell the shipper on certain days that they simply don’t have the capacity rather than over-committing or lying to customers, and then failing to meet their needs.

As “partners,” it is essential to be open and honest with each other so each side can plan accordingly. Shippers can help themselves by giving their carriers as much lead time as possible on upcoming promotions and special offers that may create equipment challenges down the road. Clearly there is no easy solution to the truck capacity issue and rising freight rates but reverting to good communication with key partners is probably the best starting point.

To stay up to date on Best Practices in Freight Management, follow me on Twitter @DanGoodwill, join the Freight Management Best Practices group on LinkedIn and subscribe to Dan’s Transportation Newspaper (http://paper.li/DanGoodwill/1342211466).

0

Comments

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Thursday, 28 March 2024

Most Recent Posts

Search


Tag Cloud

dimensional pricing CN Rail MBA cheap oil business start-up robotics freight forwarders Fire Phone cars laptop e-commerce freight marketplace Yield Improvement Cleveland Cavaliers $75000 bond asset management Facebook economy drones Transcom Fleet Leasing Distribution Tracy Matura FCA Freight Rates home delivery Whole Foods selling trucking companies Value Proposition Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration EBOR Search engine optimization Inbound Transportation rail safety computer China freight rate increases Freight Matching Derek Singleton BNSF Omni Channel USA Truck TransForce carrier conference KCS driver shortages derailments dynamic pricing Bobby Harris University of Tennessee consumer centric freight transportation UP computer security Business Development employee termination APL Emergent Strategy CSX freight agreements Right Shoring Wal-Mart Loblaw Dedicated Contract Carriage small parcel small business Rotman School of Business Software Advice 2013 Economic Forecast Electric Vehicles automation 2014 economic forecast MPG professional drivers Transplace ShipMax President Obama freight transportation conference Canadian freight market routing guide Leafs digital freight matching freight bid Life Lessons truck drivers Rail freight audit 2014 freight volumes customer engagement broker security Canada's global strategy Harper Davos speech Celadon Education Load broker risk management bulk shipping online shopping Digitization truck capacity Transloading shipping LCV's ProMiles tanker cars Doug Nix Broker autos Freight Carriers Association of Canada technology New York Times Shipper Outsourcing Sales CN Sales LinkedIn Colilers International IANA CP Rail broker bonds Management Consulting Canadian truckers Hudsons Bay Company Truckload CRM Amazon Freight Capacity solutions provider Training Driver Shortage CITA Shipper Pulse Survey Montreal Canadiens Training New Hires business security capacity shortage pipelines driverless LTL Anti-Vax NS freight broker Canadian Protests fuel surcharge Freight Recession transportation news freight transportation in 2011 Social Media 2015 Economic Forecast freight payment freight audit driver pay Accessorial Charges freight costs Canada Hockey Trump US Housing Market Dan Goodwill JB Hunt Business Transformation Strategy Trucking autonomous vehicles TMS financial management intermodal US Auto Sales Covid-19 home delibery Digital Freight Networks Scott Monty Surety bond Donald Trump Conway Uber Freight BlueGrace Logistics shipping wine Keystone Pipeline Werner 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad Infrastructure FMCSA US Manufacturing future of freight industry Crisis management natural disasters Toronto dark stores Online grocery shopping Muhammad Ali truck driver coaching Habs peak season Impeachment shipper-carrier collaboration shipper-carrier contracts Freight Retail Coronavirus cyber security Transport Capital Partners (TCP) capacity shortages recession the future of transportation Transportation energy efficiency Sales Training Adrian Gonzalez Career Advice Social Media in Transportation Comey David Tuttle Transportation Buying Trends Survey US Election Deferred Packaging Transportation service Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC economic forecasts for 2012 Dedicated Trucking NMFC Entrepreneur Canadian economy US Economy Success marketing transportation audit Global Transportation Hub Toronto Maple Leafs CSA scores Swift Geopolitics trade Load Boards NAFTA network optimization CSA Freight Shuttle System Regina freight payment Carriers General Motors Blockchain Ferromex freight RFP Sales Strategy Crude Oil by Rail Climate Change Rate per Mile Trucker Protest Finance and Transportation Stephen Harper Trade Vision trucking company acquisitions Grocery Spanx shipper-carrier roundtable FMS hiring process Tariffs 3PLTL TMP Worldwide driver Retail transportation transportation newspaper Packaging RFP 2014 freight forecast supply chain management Otto buying trucking companies FuelQuest Business skills Schneider Logistics Politics Justice Doug Davis computer protection 3PL Associates Leadership last mile delivery freight cost savings Masters in Logistics Driving for Profit Canadian Transportation & Logistics Freight contracts Reshoring Freight Management USMCA NCC Canada U.S. trade Success failure entrepreneur Blogging Job satisfaction Sales Management Twitter ELD Global experience Failure Map-21 YRCW 360ideaspace Warehousing economic outlook Microsoft mentoring FCPC Business Strategy Government Railway Association of Canada

Blog Archives

March
February
December
October
September
August
June
May
April
March
January