Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in Transportation Year in Review
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 504
  • Print

Freight Transportation in 2016 – The Year in Review


Here are the top stories in freight transportation that caught my attention over the past year.

The Tepid Economy

The North American economies underperformed the global economy and the economies of emerging markets in 2016. Business investment, a key driver of the economy, was down in 2016, driven in large part by the big drop in fortunes of the oil and gas industry. Consumer spending and employment levels remained solid in the United States and somewhat less so in Canada. US manufacturing activity increased.

US imports began an uptick as did US imports of Canadian goods, driven in part by the strong US dollar and drop in the value of the Canadian dollar. Auto manufacturing remained strong in Canada but resource and activity in other sectors remained weak. The strong US dollar depressed export activity. Overall it was a sub-par year for the American and Canadian economies. As a result, demand for over the road truckload, intermodal and LTL service was soft in 2016.

E-Commerce/The Last Mile Home Delivery Market Continue to Grow

E-Commerce has had a compound annual growth rate of 17% vs. non-E-Commerce CAGR of 3% (2000-2015). Recent data shows that 94% of Consumers stated that they placed an eCommerce order in the last 12 months and 96% plan to place an eCommerce order in the next 12 months. Approximately 50% of surveyed consumers order online at least once per month.

While final mile parcel companies continue to gain traction, UPS, FedEx and USPS still appear to control 94% of the USA parcel market. A representative from Canada Post advised attendees at the Surface Transportation Summit that they control two thirds of small parcel shipments in Canada.

Omni-channel distribution has been gaining in importance over the past few years as consumers seek more options and greater flexibility. The bad news, as reported at the recent Surface Transportation Summit, is that nobody appears to be making money with it. The need for multiple inventories and the challenges of demand planning are eroding the financial benefits of this method of distribution. To improve financial performance, companies are linking collaborative inventory planning, distributed order management, integrated order management with their TMS system and RFID technology.

Amazon and Uber Set the Pace in the Freight Industry

Amazon and Uber have identified two unique elements of freight transportation and are triggering a tidal wave of activity. They have created a unique blend of predictable logistics services, pricing options and marketing. On demand delivery services are sprouting in major markets throughout North America. Whether it is DoonDash, Sprig or Instacart in food deliveries, Washio in dry cleaning or Shyp, Roadie, Cargomatic or Deliv for carrier procurement or Transfix or Freightera for freight brokerage, there are a host of app-based delivery services that are a variation on the Uber concept. This is just a sample of the start-ups that have entered and continue to enter the industry on an almost daily basis.

About 50% of consumers shop for products online based on the available shipping methods and 75% say that free shipping “greatly impacts their purchase decision”. Next day and same day delivery options are also growing in popularity, but consumers are still unwilling to pay much for these services. Amazon, Staples, Macy’s and Best Buy are heavily invested in the same day delivery market.

Amazon has created its own set of home delivery services for consumers who order online. Amazon Prime is available for free on same day delivery, second day delivery and two hour delivery for consumers who pay the annual fee. They also provide a one hour delivery service in certain markets at a fee of $7.99 for groceries, daily essentials, gifts and other products. These two companies are revolutionizing the home delivery market.

Trucking/Rail Equipment Purchases Decline

This was a tough year for transportation equipment providers, a direct result of the slow economy. Class 8 truck production was down 30% in 2016 while semi trailer production outperformed. With rail car utilization below 70 percent and significant overcapacity, North American orders for rail cars were at very low levels.

The Ongoing Driver Shortage

Driver recruitment and retention remained one of the major problems in the trucking industry in 2016. While many companies have been raising driver wages the past few years, this is still of limited benefit in retaining qualified drivers. The major carriers continue to try a range of other approaches to address the problem. They include a greater use of driver surveys, particularly during the first six months to better understand the issues of most concern, creating driver loyalty programs, efforts to improve work life balance, providing improved exercise and recreational facilities, dispatcher training, driver mentorship programs, driver training programs and a range of other measures.

The Hanjin Bankruptcy

The August bankruptcy of Hanjin shipping line, the world’s seventh largest container line, threw ports and retailers around the world into confusion, with giant container ships marooned and merchants worrying whether tons of goods would reach their shelves. The South Korean giant’s failure was the largest and most significant bankruptcy in the container transport industry. The company stopped accepting new cargo. With its assets being frozen, ships from China to Canada found themselves refused permission to offload or take aboard containers because there were no guarantees that tugboat pilots or stevedores would be paid.

The financial struggles of Hanjin Shipping were attributable to an ongoing downturn in the container shipping industry that is the result of numerous interrelated factors such as weak global GDP, overcapacity on container vessels, "bloated" US retail inventories, changing consumer spending patterns, Chinese economic slowdown, and muted demand for container shipping. The downturn dented profits and crippled the financial health for most of the top twenty ocean carriers. Hanjin's bankruptcy created a massive ripple effect. Other businesses that rely on physical products found themselves without the expected revenue from inventory that became stuck at sea.

Cost Management

This was supposed to be a year when truckload capacity tightened and rates skyrocketed. This was supposed to be a year when higher truckload rates pushed shippers to move freight over to intermodal transportation. This was supposed to be the year when shippers had to face the music of higher driver wages and pay their carriers accordingly. It wasn’t. For much of the year, the economy was the softest it had been since 2011. The slow economy and high inventories sent spot market rates in a downward direction. Carriers were taking rate decreases.

This caused many carriers to rethink their operating strategies. Truckload carriers reined in capacity, parked trucks and/or curtailed buying new ones. LTL carriers focused on yield management and the utilization of dimensioning equipment to improve pricing accuracy. Understanding Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) of fleet equipment became a priority for fleet owners.

IoT, Big Data and Analytics

IoT (the Internet of Things) and Big Data are trendy labels for a fundamental change that will revolutionize manufacturing, distribution, and hence transportation. Unlike Self-driving vehicles or Drones, IoT and Big Data are already here. “Information is the oil of the 21stcentury, and analytics is the combustion engine” (Peter Sondergaard, Gartner Research).

Organizations are applying advanced analytics to big data to solve supply chain problems. Three ingredients are key to getting an advanced analytics initiative underway. These are: having the right people; collecting high quality data and; obtaining the best tools at the right price. Capturing the value of data through advanced analytics is very much about having people with the right mix of business knowledge, technical knowledge, innate curiosity and storytelling skills. The individuals assigned to these tasks are analysts and in some companies, are being labelled “data scientists.” The three most common uses of analytics to solve supply chain problems are Quality Control, Labour Retention and Customer Service Improvement.

TMS Market Continues to Expand

The most important development in TMS has been the growth of solutions for the mid-sized shipper. TMS has historically focused on large shippers who spend more than $100 million a year on freight. The TMS providers have broad offerings with powerful optimization engines for that market. But mid-sized shippers don’t need all that power and they’re not going to exploit that optimization with the volume of freight they manage.

Certain TMS providers are now going to market with solutions that are easy to get up and running and easy to use, many of which are cloud based with global capabilities. TMS systems are also tapping into the power of networks of transportation providers. In the past, shipper networks tended to be application specific. Today, the leading TMS providers are building interfaces into multiple networks of transportation providers for rail, trucking and international shipping.

Brexit and the Election of Donald Trump as President of the United States

These were the two biggest political events of 2016. The Brexit vote had an immediate impact on the value of the British pound. The impact of these two stunning developments on trade, economics and transportation will be felt for years to come. NAFTA and the Trans-Pacific Partnership will certainly come up for review early in 2017. The entire world will be watching to see how these stories play out.

In an otherwise flat year, these two political stories were the biggest events of the past twelve months. The year 2017 is shaping up as stepping stone to great change in North America and around the world.


To stay up to date on Best Practices in Freight Management, follow me on Twitter @DanGoodwill, join the Freight Management Best Practices group on LinkedIn and subscribe to Dan’s Transportation Newspaper (



  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Saturday, 24 June 2017

Most Recent Posts


Tag Cloud

Load broker Transplace shipping Facebook 2015 Economic Forecast freight cost savings transportation news driver shortages customer engagement Accessorial Charges robotics IANA Surety bond freight payment Dedicated Trucking 3PLTL Shipper shipping wine shipper-carrier contracts FCPC transportation newspaper Career Advice Success US Auto Sales Dedicated Contract Carriage NS President Obama FMS APL buying trucking companies bulk shipping Doug Davis Canadian freight market Training New Hires rail safety Keystone Pipeline Driving for Profit Success failure entrepreneur financial management CP Rail freight transportation in 2011 Doug Nix 2014 freight forecast freight transportation Cleveland Cavaliers Twitter Comey freight forwarders US Economy mentoring Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC Freight Carriers Association of Canada freight broker Rail Distribution LTL Life Lessons Retail transportation Toronto MBA Crisis management Deferred Packaging Derek Singleton marketing capacity shortages routing guide e-commerce US Housing Market Colilers International Conway business start-up Politics Scott Monty CN 3PL Canadian economy Transcom Fleet Leasing dimensional pricing 2013 Economic Forecast Inbound Transportation Social Media in Transportation freight audit Adrian Gonzalez freight RFP FuelQuest Training TMP Worldwide Stephen Harper Trade Vision freight rate increases Masters in Logistics CSX autonomous vehicles Transport Capital Partners (TCP) Leadership Microsoft CSA scores future of freight industry Freight Shuttle System small business Social Media shipper-carrier roundtable Werner Harper Davos speech LinkedIn NMFC economic forecasts for 2012 360ideaspace Broker Schneider Logistics Climate Change RFP Driver Shortage Infrastructure New York Times energy efficiency Railway Association of Canada 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad Tracy Matura freight transportation conference hiring process coaching Rotman School of Business home delibery selling trucking companies Business Strategy TMS $75000 bond Trump Freight Capacity USA Truck Swift FCA Rate per Mile CN Rail Fire Phone NCC Failure truck driver CRM Transloading tanker cars freight bid Yield Improvement transportation audit Otto Dan Goodwill Global experience CSA Retail 2014 economic forecast Bobby Harris Emergent Strategy Canadian Transportation & Logistics Finance and Transportation Search engine optimization truck drivers broker bonds Freight contracts Canada's global strategy driverless network optimization derailments fuel surcharge MPG Freight Rates ShipMax economy Truckload Packaging freight costs Freight Recession Canadian truckers Business skills Canada Amazon LCV's Wal-Mart peak season broker security Omni Channel drones carrier conference JB Hunt Ferromex Software Advice Warehousing David Tuttle consumer centric employee termination professional drivers shipper-carrier collaboration NAFTA driver solutions provider KCS Map-21 Loblaw freight payment freight audit Entrepreneur the future of transportation cheap oil EBOR automation Transportation Buying Trends Survey 2014 freight volumes Education Associates Job satisfaction TransForce Freight Management Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration Donald Trump Hudsons Bay Company Crude Oil by Rail University of Tennessee Freight Blogging Regina ProMiles CITA Shipper Pulse Survey BNSF Reshoring Canada U.S. trade capacity shortage FMCSA Right Shoring Celadon dynamic pricing US Manufacturing US Election intermodal freight agreements Transportation service Carriers Business Transformation Strategy UP pipelines BlueGrace Logistics Spanx Transportation trucking company acquisitions Trucking Muhammad Ali Sales Training Sales Management Management Consulting Global Transportation Hub

Blog Archives