Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in NAFTA
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 88
  • Print

The Trump Presidency – a 6-month report card


This week marks the six-month anniversary of the Donald Trump presidency. Four months ago, I posted a blog ( ) that looked at the president’s strengths and weaknesses. I thought, at the time, that this might help provide some insights into his potential for success or failure in the job. These are my thoughts at this milestone.

Clearly president Trump has made several key decisions during this period. He terminated America’s interest in the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP), took America out of the Paris Climate Accord, overturned president Obama’s decision to not permit the Keystone XL pipeline into America, changed the balance of America’s alliances in the Middle East, pushed hard for the repeal and replacement of Obamacare, initiated a review of America’s participation in NAFTA, instituted a ban on citizens from six primarily Muslim countries and oversaw the appointment of a new Supreme Court Judge, justice Neil Gorsuch.

While he has talked a lot about infrastructure spending, reducing taxes, building a wall between Mexico and the United States and tax reform, there have been few legislative achievements. Other than some positive stock market and employment numbers, most Americans are not seeing many tangible results from this president. Donald Trump’s overall approval rating stands at 39 percent, a historical low for a president in office for six months. On the bright side, his approval rating among Republicans stands at 85 percent. Looking back at my March blog, I now realize that my assessment of Donald Trump was largely correct. However, I now see some character traits more clearly and these traits are very problematic for him.

President Trump did have and still does have a vision of America. He frequently talks about “Make America Great Again” and about restoring lost manufacturing jobs to the United States. One of his biggest problems is that he lacks a coherent plan to make his vision a reality. Withdrawing from the Paris accord will not bring back lost coal mining jobs. Job growth in the energy sector will come from investing in the new sources that are growing rapidly. Withdrawing from TPP will hurt America’s trading relationships with countries in the Asia- Pacific region. His Make America a Loner Strategy is hurting the country’s relationships with many of its allies.

Rather than have a well-articulated vision for the future, president Trump seems far more focused on undoing the major initiatives of former president, Obama. While the Republicans hold majorities in three key bodies of the U.S. government, president Trump does not seem to understand the importance of setting priorities and picking the right battles to fight.

The Democrats are interested in Infrastructure. Reaching an agreement on Infrastructure would have been an easier battle to pick than health care, president Obama’s signature domestic policy achievement. By not understanding the true issues that are the essence of the health care debate and by not leading and working with the Republicans and Democrats in Congress, the president has made his presidency much harder that it must be. By not mastering the facts of the debate and creating a clear consistent message, he has undermined his chances of success and those of his party. By switching from repeal and replace Obamacare to repeal only to repeal and replace, he has lost credibility and harmed his reputation.

The self-professed dealmaker has shown an inability to make deals. For someone who has promised that he would lead America in winning, he is suffering a series of losses. For a person who loves the limelight, he tends to go into hiding at key moments when providing knowledge and leadership are essential to success.

The Russia collusion issue is going to come under great scrutiny in the months ahead. Nobody knows how this will evolve but it will certainly impact on his concentration and agenda. To be successful, president Trump will need to learn some lessons from his very challenging first six months and take action to right the ship. If he fails, he runs the risk of losing control of at least one house of Congress in 2018. This would greatly weaken his ability to govern. If he could reach common ground with Democrats on some important issues, even health care reform, this would provide huge benefits to him and his floundering presidency. If his negotiators can turn the changes to NAFTA into a Win/Win/Win exercise, he will certainly gain more support from two of America’s largest trading partners. The whole world will be watching.


To stay up to date on Best Practices in Freight Management, follow me on Twitter @DanGoodwill, join the Freight Management Best Practices group on LinkedIn and subscribe to Dan’s Transportation Newspaper (



  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Thursday, 17 August 2017

Most Recent Posts


Tag Cloud

Success failure entrepreneur Failure autonomous vehicles Education US Housing Market Omni Channel Broker Map-21 routing guide Driving for Profit freight audit online shopping Career Advice 2014 freight volumes Freight Rates truck drivers Transportation Cleveland Cavaliers dynamic pricing Rotman School of Business Wal-Mart pipelines LCV's Accessorial Charges Tracy Matura Transcom Fleet Leasing Surety bond Yield Improvement Canadian freight market Masters in Logistics Reshoring Blogging Freight Matching Leadership shipping CSX shipping wine freight payment freight audit freight costs Business Strategy solutions provider dimensional pricing mentoring CSA scores Associates Fire Phone University of Tennessee Toronto Transportation Buying Trends Survey Railway Association of Canada BNSF energy efficiency Global experience Microsoft shipper-carrier roundtable Truckload transportation audit Adrian Gonzalez Grocery Entrepreneur TransForce Search engine optimization CN $75000 bond NCC IANA e-commerce LinkedIn Whole Foods Rail 2013 Economic Forecast Canadian Transportation & Logistics bulk shipping Harper Davos speech future of freight industry transportation newspaper Derek Singleton CN Rail freight RFP freight transportation in 2011 MBA Freight Shuttle System last mile delivery Shipper freight broker New York Times KCS Facebook Crude Oil by Rail Sales Training Carriers freight payment Ferromex Regina customer engagement Otto Dedicated Trucking capacity shortage coaching ProMiles employee termination Global Transportation Hub Freight Management NAFTA driverless home delibery APL freight transportation freight rate increases drones derailments peak season trade Training New Hires TMP Worldwide professional drivers David Tuttle 3PL FMS Politics Management truck driver EBOR Canada Finance and Transportation Load Boards Inbound Transportation Packaging MPG Keystone Pipeline Software Advice capacity shortages driver shortages Canadian economy Hudsons Bay Company Trump Right Shoring CRM JB Hunt hiring process FCPC Sales Management Sales fuel surcharge Deferred Packaging LTL Infrastructure economy US Economy robotics US Auto Sales Freight Recession RFP Driver Shortage Amazon Social Media freight cost savings Success Consulting Distribution FMCSA Dedicated Contract Carriage CP Rail ShipMax FCA economic forecasts for 2012 Business Transformation Strategy Canada U.S. trade Doug Nix Transportation service automation Donald Trump trucking company acquisitions Celadon 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad small business Job satisfaction Canadian truckers Muhammad Ali freight transportation conference Climate Change Swift Warehousing BlueGrace Logistics Colilers International 2014 freight forecast Freight Capacity Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration broker security CITA Shipper Pulse Survey FuelQuest TMS Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC UP 3PLTL Werner Conway Schneider Logistics tanker cars financial management Trucking the future of transportation cheap oil home delivery freight agreements shipper-carrier contracts CSA carrier conference transportation news shipper-carrier collaboration Comey Load broker Outsourcing Sales Freight contracts US Election Bobby Harris buying trucking companies Retail Training Spanx network optimization marketing Rate per Mile Social Media in Transportation consumer centric Freight Carriers Association of Canada Scott Monty Doug Davis Emergent Strategy 360ideaspace US Manufacturing NS Life Lessons President Obama Dan Goodwill 2015 Economic Forecast business start-up driver Transport Capital Partners (TCP) freight forwarders rail safety Stephen Harper Trade Vision Transloading freight bid Freight Crisis management Loblaw Twitter 2014 economic forecast Transplace Business skills USA Truck broker bonds intermodal selling trucking companies Retail transportation Canada's global strategy NMFC

Blog Archives